Cincinnati's insurance partners you can trust
From the streets of Hyde Park to the banks of the Ohio, we protect what matters most to Cincinnati families and businesses — with policies built around your life, not a spreadsheet.
What We Offer
Coverage that fits your life in Cincinnati
Whether you're insuring your home on a tree-lined street, protecting your business in the Uptown core, or planning for the future, we tailor every policy to your real needs.
Homeowners Insurance
From bungalows in Clifton to townhomes near downtown, we cover your biggest investment against fire, storms, theft, and more.
Learn moreAuto Insurance
Comprehensive, collision, liability — whatever route you drive, we make sure you're covered on the roads around Cincinnati.
Learn moreBusiness Insurance
General liability, property, workers' comp — we help Cincinnati businesses of every size protect their operations and employees.
Learn moreLife Insurance
Term, whole, universal — we guide you through the options so your family is protected no matter what the future holds.
Learn moreFinancial Planning
Retirement, investments, estate planning — our financial advisors help Cincinnati residents build a secure future, one plan at a time.
Learn moreSpecialty Coverage
Renters, condo, flood, umbrella, and more. If it's unique to your situation, we'll find a policy that fits.
Learn more
About Us
Rooted in Cincinnati,
driven by your peace of mind
Amity Insurance Agency isn't a call center with a Cincinnati zip code. We're a local team that knows this city — from the neighborhoods to the local risks, from small businesses on Vine Street to families in the suburbs.
We started with a simple belief: insurance should feel personal, not transactional. When you work with us, you get a real person who understands your situation and fights for your claim when it counts. That's the Amity difference.
100%
Locally owned and operated
24/7
Claims support when you need it
Why Choose Us
The Amity difference
We're not the biggest agency in town — and that's exactly why Cincinnati trusts us.
Personal Attention
You'll always know your agent's name. No call queues, no scripts — just someone who knows your policy by heart.
Fast Response Times
Questions? Call us. Claims? We're on it. We pride ourselves on answering the phone and moving quickly.
Honest Advice
We'll tell you what you actually need — not what's most expensive. No upselling, no fine print surprises.
Community Focused
We sponsor little league, support local charities, and show up. This is our home, too.
Get in Touch
Let's talk about
protecting what matters
Whether you need a quick quote or a full coverage review, we're here. Reach out by phone, email, or stop by our office on Montgomery Road — we'll make time for you.
Request a Free Quote
Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within one business day.
Message Sent!
We'll be in touch within one business day.
